Skip to content
The BT06 standard settling tank on site dewatering
Prime Fluid Management18 November 20265 min read

Settling Tank Types Compared – Which Option Suits Your Site?

Comparing Settling Tanks – Standard, Hybrid and Lamella Clarifiers
4:07

A bigger settling tank isn't always the answer to cloudy site water. Across New Zealand, sand in groundwater can settle readily, while finer sediment may stay suspended much longer.

What matters is how the sediment behaves – not just how much water you're pumping.

We compare standard, hybrid and lamella clarifier settling tanks. We also explain how sediment, pumping arrangements and site requirements influence equipment selection.

Settling-tanks-lamella-clarifier-hybrid-standard

Prime's lamella clarifier, hybrid and standard settling tanks

 

 

Key takeaways

  • Start with the water – sediment type and settling behaviour help determine which equipment suits the job.
  • Consider the pumping setup – intake position and flow affect how much sediment reaches treatment equipment.
  • Match treatment to site requirements – space, discharge limits and sludge handling can influence your site setup.

How quickly does the sediment settle?

Before recommending equipment, Prime's Christchurch team typically asks for a 20L water sample and carries out a simple bench test – to check how readily the sediment settles and whether it needs further treatment.

“Our experience gives us a clear idea of what ground conditions to expect, but we still test the water. That helps us understand the sediment and narrow down the treatment options.”

Richard Haywood – Senior Project Manager Hire Operations, Prime Fluid Management

 

Prime's HST09 hybrid settling tank with mesh lid and pipework on site.

A hybrid settling tank and extra water treatment equipment in use on a construction site in Napier

How do the three settling options compare?

Standard, hybrid and lamella tanks all use gravity to separate sediment from water. Their internal designs provide different settling areas.

Equipment

How It Works

When To Consider It

Standard settling tank

Baffles control water flow, giving solids time to settle

For pre-settling or when there’s sand, course silt or other readily settling solids

Hybrid settling tank

Baffles and honeycomb media increase the available settling area

When a standard tank needs extra settling capacity within a compact setup

Lamella clarifier

Closely spaced inclined plates provide substantial settling area in a compact footprint

Finer settleable solids, tighter discharge requirements or limited site space

 

How does pumping affect settling tank selection?

How groundwater is collected can affect the amount of sediment reaching a settling tank.

Wellpointing systems often produce relatively clear water, while pumping directly from an active excavation can draw in more sediment as digging disturbs the ground.

On an Auckland job, Prime suggested positioning a submersible pump inside a separate PVC well rather than directly in an active excavation. The aim was to reduce the amount of disturbed sediment entering the treatment equipment.

“Our process is to avoid as much sludge as possible going into the tank.”

Brent Petrie – Hire Operations Manager, Prime Fluid Management

 

HST09-hybrid-settling-tank-water-treatment-setup-napier

Hybrid settling tank connected to another treatment tank on site in Napier

When is a standard settling tank not enough?

When sediment takes longer to settle, a standard tank may not achieve the required discharge quality on its own. Hybrid or lamella tanks provide additional settling area, while chemical dosing can help finer suspended particles bind together and settle.

On a wellpointing job in Blenheim, site restrictions influenced how Prime arranged the settling tanks.

“Space dictated the setup. We couldn't use chemicals on that job – so instead of dosing the water, we stacked two hybrid tanks to give it more time to settle.”

Richard Haywood

Stacking isn't suitable for every job. It depends on tank design, ground support and installation requirements.

Can settling equipment keep up with dewatering? 

The treatment setup needs to handle the required pumping rate without slowing dewatering.

“If you restrict the flow, it means you're not going to get the water out of the ground.”

Richard Haywood

But water moving too quickly through a settling tank gives suspended solids less time to settle – potentially affecting discharge quality.

Lamella-hybrid-standard-settling-tanks-infographic

Plan water treatment before pumping starts

Before choosing settling equipment, consider:

  • Water characteristics – sediment type, settling behaviour and potential changes in sediment loading
  • Pumping arrangement – expected and peak flows, plus intake position
  • Discharge requirements – consent limits, sampling and any further treatment
  • Site constraints – available space, ground support, pipework, access and sludge removal.

Getting Prime involved early leaves more time to assess the water and plan where treatment equipment will go.

“The biggest mistake is getting us involved too late. Sometimes contractors contact us after they've been shut down for discharging dirty water – and then they need everything sorted quickly.”

Richard Haywood

Explore Prime's settling tanks and bags and EnviroHub lamella clarifiers – or speak with our team about your water treatment requirements.

FAQs about settling tanks and bags

What’s the difference between a standard and hybrid settling tank?

Standard tanks use internal baffles to slow water and allow solids to settle. Hybrid tanks add honeycomb settling tubes for more settling area. Explore Prime’s settling tanks and bags range.

Can a standard settling tank remove fine silt or clay?

It depends on how readily the particles settle. Very fine silt and clay can remain suspended, so you may need chemical dosing or further treatment to meet discharge requirements.

Do lamella clarifiers always need chemical dosing?

No – lamella clarifiers use gravity to settle suspended solids. Chemical dosing is optional and can help finer particles bind together and settle more readily. Find out more about dosing systems.

 

Can settling tanks be stacked?

Yes – some standard and hybrid tanks can be stacked to suit site constraints or provide extra settling time. Prime can confirm suitable configurations, ground support and installation requirements.

Can settling bags replace a settling tank?

Not usually for continuous, high-volume pumping. Settling bags are often better suited to dewatering collected sludge – although they can also work in suitable lower-flow applications.

How can you tell if a settling tank is working effectively?

Sample the treated water and compare results with the site's discharge requirements. Visual clarity can help identify problems but doesn't replace water quality testing.

For sites requiring ongoing readings and alerts, see Prime's water quality monitoring options.


 

RELATED ARTICLES